Batch Review — csg-03-11a-the-reality-of-love-sec1-5
Source: resources/CSG/Book03/csg-03-11-the-reality-of-love.md — Sections 1–5 only
Scope: 10 atomics
Date: 2026-05-27
Variant: foundation-pass
Class: CSG
Style profile: anthology of SMM teachings, structured by editors; attribution to underlying speech where indicated (date in citation).
Pre-flight summary (Phase A)
- Citation grammar:
[[resources/CSG/Book03/csg-03-11-the-reality-of-love#nm-subsection-heading|N.M. Subsection heading]] - Proposed batch: 10 H2 leaf units (§§1.1, 1.2, 2.1, 2.2, 3.1, 3.2, 4.1, 4.2, 5.1, 5.2)
- Soft-ceiling check: under 14 leaf units ✓
- Staging path:
staging/csg-03-11a-the-reality-of-love-sec1-5/(collision check: clear) - Anticipated questions resolved:
- Q1 (heading concatenation bug in csg-03-10/12/13/14, H2 line-break bug in csg-03-11): cleaned up first — two commits before this batch began:
- a5eb8b3 fix(ingest): de-fold H1 prose-bug in CSG Book03 chapters
- 5d57b69 fix(ingest): de-fold split H2 headings in CSG Book03 chapter 2
- Q2 (csg-03-11 over 14-leaf ceiling): accepted split — this batch = 11a §§1–5 (10 leaves); 11b §§6–9 (6 leaves) is a follow-on batch.
- Q3 (lean Variant-2 only): confirmed.
- Q1 (heading concatenation bug in csg-03-10/12/13/14, H2 line-break bug in csg-03-11): cleaned up first — two commits before this batch began:
Atomics
| File | Title | Tags |
|---|---|---|
csg-gods-love-as-original-source-and-vertical-axis.md | God’s Love Is the Original Source and Vertical Axis of All Love | love, principle-of-creation, give-and-take |
csg-god-plants-loves-root-in-the-partner-not-himself.md | God Plants Love’s Root in the Partner, Not Within Himself | love, principle-of-creation, purpose-of-creation, give-and-take |
csg-true-parents-as-sinless-ancestor-and-horizontal-savior.md | True Parents Are the Sinless Ancestor and Horizontal Savior of Humankind | true-parents, restoration, messiah, lineage |
csg-rebirth-through-true-parents-lineage-is-the-mechanism-of-salvation.md | Rebirth Through True Parents’ Lineage Is the Mechanism of Salvation | true-parents, lineage, restoration, blessing, fall |
csg-parental-love-as-essential-and-unchanging-form.md | Parental Love Is the Essential and Unchanging Form of Love | love, family, give-and-take, principle-of-creation |
csg-parental-love-expands-through-sharing-not-diminishes.md | Parental Love Expands Through Sharing Rather Than Diminishing | love, family, give-and-take, principle-of-creation |
csg-conjugal-love-as-horizontal-flower-of-universe.md | Conjugal Love Is the Horizontal Flower of the Universe | love, family, blessing, dual-characteristics, four-position-foundation |
csg-conjugal-love-is-exclusive-unlike-parental-love.md | Conjugal Love Is Exclusive — Sharing Destroys It, Unlike Parental Love | love, family, principle-of-creation, blessing |
csg-sexual-organs-as-original-palace-of-love-life-lineage.md | Sexual Organs Are the Original Palace of Love, Life, and Lineage | love, lineage, fall, blessing, principle-of-creation |
csg-true-love-is-innate-not-taught.md | True Love Is Innate and Experiential, Not Taught | love, principle-of-creation, give-and-take |
Glossary / Person updates
- New stubs proposed (Phase C): none. All inline wikilinks (
[[true-parents]],[[blessing]],[[four-position-foundation]],[[principle-of-creation]]) resolve to existing glossary entries. - Existing entries newly hit by wikilinks:
[[true-parents]]— newly referenced by csg-true-parents-as-sinless-ancestor-and-horizontal-savior[[blessing]]— newly referenced by 3 atomics (§§2.2, 4.1, 5.1)[[four-position-foundation]]— newly referenced by csg-conjugal-love-as-horizontal-flower-of-universe[[principle-of-creation]]— newly referenced by csg-conjugal-love-is-exclusive-unlike-parental-love
- Person wikilinks: none added. CSG-class convention (per existing atomics in
/reference/csg-*.md) keeps Adam/Eve/Jesus mentions in narrative prose without[[…]]. Maintained.
Suspected duplicates / cross-batch notes
| New atomic | Candidate match | Where | Similarity note |
|---|---|---|---|
csg-gods-love-as-original-source-and-vertical-axis | [[csg-god-cannot-love-without-a-partner]] | /reference/ | Both touch God-as-source-of-love. My atomic adds vertical-axis geometry (vertical/horizontal engrafting at 90°); the existing atomic emphasizes partner-dependence. Adjacent, not redundant. Keep both. |
csg-gods-love-as-original-source-and-vertical-axis | [[vertical-and-horizontal-parental-love]] | staging/csg-book02/ | csg-book02 has a unified vertical/horizontal atomic decomposing into parental love specifically; mine generalizes the vertical-axis principle to all love. Possible merge candidate or complementary framing — review side-by-side. |
csg-god-plants-loves-root-in-the-partner-not-himself | [[csg-god-cannot-love-without-a-partner]] | /reference/ | Same theological territory. My atomic isolates the “love-root planted in partner, not in God” formulation (177-269, 1988.5.20) as a distinct move beyond “love requires a partner.” Worth keeping as a refinement; consider re-linking the existing atomic to cite mine. |
csg-god-plants-loves-root-in-the-partner-not-himself | [[csg-parent-child-relation-is-center-of-universe]] | /reference/ | Both leaves cite the same SMM teaching (19-158, 1965.1.1) about the parent-child relationship being the root of the universe. My §1.2 atomic only quotes the “love-root in partner” angle, not the parent-child quote, so direct content-overlap is minimal — but the source leaves do overlap. Reviewer may prefer to add this Book03 §1.2 to the existing atomic’s sources: rather than create a parallel atomic. |
csg-rebirth-through-true-parents-lineage-is-the-mechanism-of-salvation | [[csg-lineage-change-required-for-direct-sonship]] | /reference/ | Close — both describe lineage transfer via True Parents. Existing atomic emphasizes the requirement of lineage change; mine extends to the broader claim that “salvation = genealogical rebirth (not declarative justification).” Possible merge; alternative is to keep mine as the framing atomic and link to the existing one for the doctrinal detail. |
csg-true-parents-as-sinless-ancestor-and-horizontal-savior | [[csg-true-parents-as-gods-embodied-form]] | /reference/ | Different angle. Existing atomic frames True Parents as God’s incarnate body (vertical→horizontal embodiment); mine frames the Messiah-as-horizontal-True-Father-not-God claim against Christianity. Complementary. Keep both. |
csg-true-parents-as-sinless-ancestor-and-horizontal-savior | [[true-parents-defined-as-those-with-perfect-love]] | staging/csg-book02/ | Possible overlap — review side-by-side. Different definitional axes (perfect-love vs sinless-ancestor + horizontal-savior). |
csg-conjugal-love-is-exclusive-unlike-parental-love | [[sexual-order-as-core-of-ethics]] | staging/unificationthought/ | UT-source vs CSG-source on overlapping moral territory. Different framings (ethics-of-order vs structural-exclusivity). Keep both — distinct citation classes per ADR-0020. |
csg-sexual-organs-as-original-palace-of-love-life-lineage | [[sexual-norm-as-supreme-and-perpetual-directive]] | staging/unificationthought/ | Same UT-vs-CSG split. Keep both. |
Tag-registry requests
| Proposed tag | Justification | Trigger atomic |
|---|
(None — every tag used appears in _meta/tags.md.)
Linking applied (Phase C)
related:additions: 29 cross-refs across 10 atomics (2–3 per atomic).- Inline glossary wikilinks added: 5 (
[[true-parents]],[[blessing]]×2,[[four-position-foundation]],[[principle-of-creation]]). - Inline person wikilinks added: 0 (CSG convention — no
[[adam]]/[[eve]]/[[jesus]]for narrative mentions). - Suspected duplicates flagged: 9 (see table above).
- New glossary stubs proposed: 0.
Validation failures (Phase B)
| Atomic | Validation rule failed | Notes |
|---|
(None. All 10 atomics + this REVIEW.md passed python3 scripts/pre-commit-hook.py against the staged set.)
Parked items (Phase D)
Appended to _meta/parking/*.md on finalize.
- Threads (0 entries)
- Questions (3 entries — see
_meta/parking/questions.md)- “Does the ‘love-root planted in the partner’ formulation entail that God’s love is incomplete without the actualized partner? How does this reconcile with classical-theist divine aseity?” (§1.2, default-park per ADR-0021)
- “If the Fall is recast as a sexual-order violation (per §5.1), what role remains for the act-of-disobedience reading dominant in Christian theology? Are the two readings additive or mutually exclusive?” (§5.1, default-park)
- “How does the strict conjugal-exclusivity claim (§4.2) cohere with SMM’s own polygynous practice in pre-Blessing history, or with the Blessing of non-monogamous historical figures?” (§4.2, default-park)
- Web-search (0 entries)
How to review
- Open
staging/csg-03-11a-the-reality-of-love-sec1-5/in Obsidian or VS Code. - Read the 10 atomics in any order. Edit, reject, or accept in place. Atomics are filename-keyed wikilinks; moving them later is incidental.
- Resolve the 9 suspected-duplicate rows above — decisions to make: merge into existing atomic / keep both / re-anchor existing atomic to also cite Book03 §X. Cross-batch overlaps with
staging/csg-book02/andstaging/unificationthought/can be deferred if those batches haven’t finalized yet. - Decide which of the 3 parked questions (if any) should be promoted to
/questions/immediately (default is park per ADR-0021 Variant-2; user override at this gate). - Say “approved” + any edits. I’ll finalize, hook validates.