Batch Review — csg-book07-etiquette-and-tradition

Source: resources/CSG/Book07/ (4 chapter files) Scope: 51 atomics Date: 2026-05-27 Variant: foundation-pass Class: CSG Style profile: Anthology of SMM teachings, structured by editors; attribute to underlying speech where indicated (date in citation).

Pre-flight summary (Phase A)

Citation grammar: [[resources/CSG/Book07/{file}#h2-heading-text|H2 heading text]] — verbatim H2 anchor per ADR-0024.
Sample anchor: [[resources/CSG/Book07/csg-07-01-etiquette-for-attending-god#11-god-and-human-beings-relate-as-parent-and-child|1.1. God and human beings relate as parent and child]].
Proposed batch: whole CSG Book07, 4 chapter files, 73 H2 subsections. Target ~50-60 atomics — many H2 leaves (especially Ch4 §9 daily-living items: clothes, hairstyle, fingernails, walking, sleeping) are short etiquette tactical content and yield 0 atomics; doctrinal/theological leaves yield 1 atomic each.
Soft-ceiling check: 4 source files is well under the ~14-unit soft ceiling. Treating the whole book as one batch matches the csg-book04-true-family precedent.
Staging path: staging/csg-book07-etiquette-and-tradition/ (collision check: clear).
Archive path: _meta/batch-reviews/csg-book07-etiquette-and-tradition.md (collision check: clear).
Heading-structure notes:
- Ch4 Section 7 (“Love between Siblings”) has the prose-into-heading bug — first paragraph concatenated into the # Section 7. ... line, and no H2 subheading. Atomization for that section cites the Section 7 H1 anchor verbatim.
- Ch4 §11.2 “Holy Candles” uses H3 sub-leaves (### 11.2.1. Shimjung Candle, etc.) instead of H2; H3 anchors used per ADR-0024.
- Ch4 §13.1 heading wraps awkwardly (“Laws on ancestor worship were originally part of heavenly” then “law.” starts the body) — atomic cites the H2 line verbatim as it appears.
- Citation dates: every SMM quote has a (volume-page, YYYY.M.D) trailer; atomics carry those dates inline alongside the wikilink, matching Book04 precedent.
Anticipated questions resolved (auto-confirmed defaults, user is AFK):
- Heading anomalies (Ch4 §7 prose-bug, Ch4 §13.1 wrap, Ch4 §11.2 H3 leaves) — default: proceed as-is and flag.
- Recurring terms not in /glossary/ (e.g., hoondokhae already exists, but seunghwa, holy-salt, pledge-service, shimjung-candle, cain-abel-pattern exists, tribal-messiah exists) — default: propose new stubs in REVIEW; do not create glossary files in this batch.
- Tag-registry gap candidates (attendance, ritual, tradition) — default: proceed with existing tags (worship, prayer, family, true-parents, ecclesiology); list any genuinely needed new tag in REVIEW.
- Overlap with staging/csg-book04-true-family/ (parental love, conjugal love, three generations atomics), and existing /reference/ (worship, prayer, blessing themes), and _meta/batch-reviews/csg-book02 lineage atomics — default: atomize anyway and flag suspected duplicates.
- Variant — default: lean Variant-2 foundation-pass.

Anticipated questions (Gate 1)

Source files exhibit minor heading anomalies (Ch4 §7 prose-into-heading bug, Ch4 §13.1 wrap, Ch4 §11.2 uses H3 leaves). Proceed as-is and flag, halt for source cleanup, or abort? Recommended default: proceed as-is and flag.
Recurring CSG-specific terms not yet in /glossary/ — seunghwa (ascension/funeral), holy-salt, pledge-service, shimjung-candle, ae-cheon-candle, unification-candle, attendance (in the CSG sense of “salvation through attendance”). Propose stubs at finalize, block until stubs exist, or skip wikilinks for these terms? Recommended default: propose stubs in REVIEW; do not create glossary files in this batch.
Tag-registry gap candidates: attendance (CSG salvation-by-attendance), tradition, ritual, tithing, witnessing. Most are covered by existing worship, prayer, family, true-parents, ecclesiology, evangelism. Propose new tag(s) only if a clear gap shows up. Recommended default: proceed with existing tags and list any needed new tag in REVIEW.
Likely overlap with staging/csg-book04-true-family/ (siblings, three-generations, parental love), and existing /reference/ and other staging batches. Atomize anyway and flag, skip overlapping sections, or merge into existing notes? Recommended default: atomize anyway and flag suspected duplicates; Gate 2 review decides merges.
Confirm Variant-2 foundation-pass mode: lean atomics only, no counter-argument sections or thread seeding. Recommended default: proceed lean.

Atomics

File	Title	Tags
`csg-abel-is-defined-by-public-mindedness.md`	Abel Is Defined by Public-Mindedness, Not Seniority	populism, restoration, ecclesiology, fall
`csg-attendance-age-demands-the-highest-codified-law.md`	The Attendance Age Demands the Highest Codified Law	true-parents, restoration, indemnity, family
`csg-attending-true-parents-qualifies-for-heaven.md`	Attending True Parents Qualifies for Heaven	salvation, true-parents, spirit-world, eschatology
`csg-becoming-sons-and-daughters-of-true-parents.md`	Becoming Sons and Daughters of True Parents	true-parents, family, lineage, restoration
`csg-blessed-families-are-tribal-messiahs.md`	Blessed Families Are Tribal Messiahs	true-parents, restoration, family, messiah
`csg-blessed-families-establish-god-centered-rules.md`	Blessed Families Must Establish God-Centered Rules	family, blessing, restoration, four-position-foundation
`csg-breaking-heavenly-laws-displeases-god.md`	Breaking Heavenly Laws Displeases God	worship, sin, restoration, divine-constraint
`csg-cain-abel-order-among-members.md`	Cain-Abel Order among Members	restoration, family, fall, indemnity
`csg-church-aims-at-gods-nation-not-itself.md`	The Church Aims at God’s Nation, Not Itself	ecclesiology, providence, restoration, true-parents
`csg-church-is-an-extension-of-the-family.md`	The Church Is an Extension of the Family	ecclesiology, family, love, four-position-foundation
`csg-church-leader-must-practice-a-public-life.md`	A Church Leader Must Practice a Public Life	ecclesiology, worship, sacrifice⚠, populism
`csg-completed-testament-age-is-salvation-through-attendance.md`	Completed Testament Age Is Salvation through Attendance	salvation, providence, true-parents, worship
`csg-ethics-are-rooted-in-the-emotion-of-love.md`	Ethics Are Rooted in the Emotion of Love	love, family, personhood, principle-of-creation
`csg-faith-education-outranks-school-education.md`	Faith Education Outranks School Education	family, love, true-parents, personhood
`csg-family-faith-life-educates-children.md`	Family Faith Life Educates Children by Example	family, worship, prayer, true-parents
`csg-family-life-replaces-vague-living-with-purpose.md`	Family Life Replaces Vague Living with Purpose	family, love, purpose-of-creation, true-parents
`csg-filial-son-walks-the-path-straight.md`	The Filial Son Walks the Path Straight	true-parents, restoration, love, providence
`csg-frugality-returns-ownership-to-god.md`	Frugality Returns Ownership to God	family, true-parents, purpose-of-creation, providence
`csg-indemnity-fund-pays-the-price-of-jesus-betrayal.md`	The Indemnity Fund Pays the Price of Jesus’ Betrayal	indemnity, restoration, messiah, providence
`csg-indemnity-precedes-restoration.md`	Indemnity Precedes Restoration; There Is No Shortcut	indemnity, restoration, providence, fall
`csg-leaders-raise-members-through-devoted-investment.md`	Leaders Raise Members through Devoted Investment	ecclesiology, love, evangelism, church-growth
`csg-living-a-life-of-oneness-with-god.md`	Living a Life of Oneness with God	worship, prayer, personhood, love
`csg-living-for-others-is-the-universal-law.md`	Living for the Sake of Others Is the Universal Law	love, principle-of-creation, give-and-take, true-parents
`csg-members-are-family-by-same-lineage-of-heart.md`	Members Are Family by the Same Lineage of Heart	family, ecclesiology, love, lineage
`csg-night-services-break-the-realm-of-darkness.md`	Night and Early-Morning Services Break the Realm of Darkness	worship, prayer, spirit-world, ecclesiology
`csg-parent-child-bond-is-the-universal-standard.md`	Parent-Child Bond Is the Universal Standard of Relationship	purpose-of-creation, love, family, four-position-foundation
`csg-parents-exist-for-their-children.md`	Parents Exist for Their Children	family, love, principle-of-creation, personhood
`csg-parents-must-first-practice-what-they-teach.md`	Parents Must First Practice What They Teach	family, true-parents, ecclesiology, love
`csg-people-should-not-be-treated-lightly.md`	People Should Not Be Treated Lightly	love, personhood, family, populism
`csg-prayer-follows-an-order-public-first.md`	Prayer Follows an Order — Public First	prayer, providence, worship, restoration
`csg-prayer-is-the-hearts-storehouse.md`	Prayer Is the Heart’s Storehouse	prayer, family, providence, love
`csg-praying-in-true-parents-name-not-jesus.md`	Praying in True Parents’ Name, Not Jesus’	prayer, true-parents, messiah, salvation
`csg-sermons-must-be-given-with-life-intensity.md`	Sermons Must Be Given with Life Intensity	worship, ecclesiology, evangelism, prayer
`csg-service-and-sacrifice-are-the-path-of-true-love.md`	Service and Sacrifice Are the Path of True Love	love, sacrifice⚠, restoration, indemnity
`csg-seven-day-fast-registers-the-body-in-spirit-world.md`	The Seven-Day Fast Registers the Body in the Spirit World	restoration, indemnity, spirit-world, messiah
`csg-sex-and-public-money-disqualify-leaders.md`	Sex and Public-Money Misuse Disqualify Leaders	ecclesiology, fall, sin, fallen-nature
`csg-siblings-make-the-family-three-dimensional.md`	Siblings Make the Family Three-Dimensional	family, love, four-position-foundation, world-peace
`csg-sincerity-moves-heaven.md`	Sincerity Moves Heaven	prayer, true-parents, love, worship
`csg-social-relationships-expand-from-gods-love.md`	Social Relationships Expand from God’s Love	love, world-peace, family, personhood
`csg-spouses-are-companions-for-life.md`	Spouses Are Companions for Life	family, love, blessing, personhood
`csg-spouses-are-comrades-in-faith.md`	Spouses Are Comrades in Faith	family, blessing, dual-characteristics, four-position-foundation
`csg-those-who-live-for-others-become-the-center.md`	Those Who Live for Others Become the Center	love, family, true-parents, populism
`csg-thrift-serves-the-nation-and-the-world.md`	Thrift Serves the Nation and the World, Not the Self	world-peace, providence, populism, ecclesiology
`csg-time-of-worship-is-a-time-to-meet-god.md`	The Time of Worship Is a Time to Meet God	worship, prayer, sin, restoration
`csg-tithing-applies-to-time-and-children.md`	Tithing Applies to Time and Children, Not Only Money	family, worship, providence, ecclesiology
`csg-tithing-is-a-heavenly-duty.md`	Tithing Is a Heavenly Duty	worship, indemnity, restoration, providence
`csg-tradition-is-passed-on-by-parents.md`	Tradition Is Passed On by Parents, Not by Schools	family, true-parents, personhood, love
`csg-true-fathers-sermons-come-from-life-not-books.md`	True Father’s Sermons Come from Life, Not Books	worship, true-parents, evangelism, ecclesiology
`csg-true-parents-are-the-hope-of-all-humankind.md`	True Parents Are the Hope of All Humankind	true-parents, messiah, eschatology, lineage
`csg-true-parents-picture-protects-the-home.md`	True Parents’ Picture Protects the Home	true-parents, family, spirit-world, blessing
`csg-witnessing-creates-ones-second-self.md`	Witnessing Creates One’s Second Self	evangelism, love, restoration, spirit-world

⚠ = tag awaits registry approval (see “Tag-registry requests” below).

Glossary / Person updates

New stubs proposed (Phase C):
- attendance — recurring Book07 term for “salvation through attendance” / “age of justification by attendance”; the operating soteriological mode of the Completed Testament Age in CSG. Used as a noun across the whole book; deserves a glossary anchor.
- seunghwa — recurring Book07 term for the Unification funeral / ascension rite; mentioned in Ch4 §11/§13 etiquette material. Korean term, not currently glossed.
- holy-salt — recurring Book07 term for the salt-blessing rite used to sanctify objects/spaces; tactical etiquette term repeatedly invoked.
- pledge-service — recurring Book07 term for the codified Family Pledge devotional; key training-rhythm term cited in csg-family-faith-life-educates-children.
- shimjung-candle / ae-cheon-candle / unification-candle — recurring Book07 Ch4 §11.2 candle vocabulary; ritual-grammar terms.
- indemnity-fund — recurring Book07 §5.3 monetary-indemnity term; could fold into existing indemnity glossary or stand alone.
- tribal-messiahship — already cross-flagged in staging/csg-book09-blessing-and-blessed-families/; recurs in Book07 atomic csg-blessed-families-are-tribal-messiahs.
Existing glossary entries newly hit by wikilinks in this batch: true-parents, tribal-messiah, indemnity, restoration, blessing, four-position-foundation, give-and-take-action, populist-church, ecclesiology, sunday-service-as-harvest, worship-leader, dual-characteristics, jeong-seong, cain-abel-pattern, messiah, lineage, fall, completed-testament-age, spirit-world, purpose-of-creation, principle-of-creation, love.
Existing person entries newly hit by wikilinks: adam, eve, jesus, cain, abel.

Suspected duplicates / cross-batch notes

New atomic	Candidate match	Where	Similarity note
`csg-attending-true-parents-qualifies-for-heaven.md`	`[[dp-completion-stage-completed-testament-age-justification-by-attendance-divine-spirit]]`; `[[dp-individual-must-fulfill-vertical-indemnity-horizontally-by-attending-second-advent]]`; `[[dp-first-resurrection-belongs-to-those-who-attend-christ-at-second-advent]]`	`/reference/`	DP-side already covers “justification by attendance” doctrinally; Book07 angle is the etiquette/practice side. Possibly fold or cross-link only.
`csg-completed-testament-age-is-salvation-through-attendance.md`	`[[dp-completion-stage-completed-testament-age-justification-by-attendance-divine-spirit]]`; `[[completed-testament-age]]` glossary	`/reference/`, `/glossary/`	Near-doctrinal-duplicate of DP atomic + glossary; Book07 angle is the periodization-as-soteriology framing.
`csg-becoming-sons-and-daughters-of-true-parents.md`	`[[core-uc-message-is-the-true-parents-claim]]`; `[[csg-true-parents-as-gods-embodied-form]]`; `staging/csg-book02/messiah-is-the-true-parent.md`; `staging/csg-book02/blessed-families-as-tribal-representatives-of-true-parents.md`	`/reference/`, `staging/csg-book02/`	Same True-Parents-as-domestic-fact framing as Book02 cluster; Book07 angle is the three-generation household + filial obligation.
`csg-true-parents-are-the-hope-of-all-humankind.md`	`[[csg-true-parents-as-gods-embodied-form]]`; `staging/csg-book02/three-reasons-true-parents-absolutely-needed.md`; `staging/csg-book02/restoration-history-is-the-history-of-finding-true-parents.md`; `staging/csg-book09-blessing-and-blessed-families/csg-messiah-needed-as-true-parents.md`	`/reference/`, `staging/csg-book02/`, `staging/csg-book09-.../`	Adjacent “True Parents are the goal of history” framings recur across Book01-02-07-09. Cluster review for merges.
`csg-blessed-families-are-tribal-messiahs.md`	`staging/csg-book02/blessed-families-as-tribal-representatives-of-true-parents.md`; `staging/csg-book02/blessed-families-inherit-true-parents-tribal-mission.md`; `staging/csg-book09-blessing-and-blessed-families/csg-430-couples-instructed-to-be-tribal-messiahs.md`; `staging/csg-book10-completed-testament-age/csg-chil-il-jeol-tribal-messiahship-1991.md`; `staging/csg-book16-family-pledge/csg-tribal-messiahs-connect-the-individual-to-the-original-homeland.md`	`staging/csg-book02/`, `staging/csg-book09-.../`, `staging/csg-book10-.../`, `staging/csg-book16-.../`	Tribal-messiah is a vault-wide recurring claim. Book07 angle is the 1989 proclamation + Kim-clan example. Cross-cluster review needed once all Book staging batches finalize.
`csg-true-parents-picture-protects-the-home.md`	`staging/csg-book02/displaying-true-parents-photograph-as-tribal-messiah-work.md`	`staging/csg-book02/`	Same physical-picture-as-sacramental claim. Different scriptural analogy (Book07 = Passover lamb’s blood; Book02 = tribal-messiah witness work).
`csg-praying-in-true-parents-name-not-jesus.md`	`staging/csg-book02/prayer-in-true-parents-name-as-cosmic-not-personal.md`	`staging/csg-book02/`	Same name-of-prayer doctrinal claim. Book07 angle is dispensational substitution; Book02 angle is cosmic-not-personal scope. Likely strong-merge candidate.
`csg-filial-son-walks-the-path-straight.md`	`[[csg-filial-child-walks-road-of-restoration]]`; `staging/csg-book14-loyalty-and-filial-piety/csg-genuine-filial-piety-costs-your-life.md`; `staging/csg-book14-loyalty-and-filial-piety/csg-filial-piety-tested-in-difficulty.md`	`/reference/`, `staging/csg-book14-.../`	Same “filial-son walks straight at cost of life” framing recurs across Book01/14. Book07 angle is directional-metaphor + True Father’s autobiography.
`csg-cain-abel-order-among-members.md`	`[[dp-cain-abel-pattern-pervades-all-relationships-from-individual-to-world]]`; `[[dp-cain-abel-positions-determined-by-eves-two-fallen-acts]]`; `[[dp-foundation-of-substance-removes-fallen-nature-via-cain-abel-indemnity]]`; `[[cain-abel-pattern]]` glossary	`/reference/`, `/glossary/`	DP atomics already cover Cain-Abel doctrine; Book07 angle is members’-interpersonal-application. Cross-link rather than merge.
`csg-abel-is-defined-by-public-mindedness.md`	`[[dp-cain-abel-pattern-pervades-all-relationships-from-individual-to-world]]`; `[[moons-early-ministry-as-populist-template]]`	`/reference/`	Same public-mindedness-defines-Abel logic. Book07 angle is church-internal sociology (seniority vs. public-mindedness).
`csg-indemnity-precedes-restoration.md`	`[[dp-restoration-through-indemnity-is-condition-fulfillment-not-payment]]`; `[[dp-history-is-providence-of-restoration-through-indemnity]]`; `[[dp-three-types-of-indemnity-equal-lesser-greater]]`; `[[indemnity]]` glossary	`/reference/`, `/glossary/`	Same doctrinal claim as DP atomics + glossary. Book07 angle is the pastoral exhortation (“if you don’t like indemnity you’re on Satan’s side”).
`csg-indemnity-fund-pays-the-price-of-jesus-betrayal.md`	`[[dp-numerical-indemnity-periods-twelve-four-twenty-one-forty-restore-pre-fall-numbers]]`; `staging/csg-book08-indemnity-restoration/*.md` (general overlap)	`/reference/`, `staging/csg-book08-.../`	Numerological indemnity-fund framing. Book07 is the monetary-condition specific case. Book08 batch should be cross-referenced.
`csg-tithing-is-a-heavenly-duty.md`	None obvious	—	Tithing-as-restoration-arithmetic is a Book07-specific framing; no near-duplicate detected.
`csg-spouses-are-companions-for-life.md`; `csg-spouses-are-comrades-in-faith.md`	`staging/csg-book04-true-family/csg-ideal-spouses-live-for-each-other.md`; `staging/csg-book04-true-family/csg-spouses-own-each-others-love-organs.md`	`staging/csg-book04-true-family/`	Adjacent spousal-union claims. Book04 angle is ontological-merger; Book07 angle is codified daily-order + walking-stick metaphor.
`csg-siblings-make-the-family-three-dimensional.md`	`staging/csg-book04-true-family/csg-siblings-teach-love-for-parents-whole-life.md`	`staging/csg-book04-true-family/`	Same sibling-cosmology claim; Book04 emphasizes the relational-curriculum, Book07 emphasizes the geometric four-directions model.
`csg-becoming-sons-and-daughters-of-true-parents.md`; `csg-attending-true-parents-qualifies-for-heaven.md`	`staging/csg-book04-true-family/csg-fallen-people-hope-to-meet-true-parents.md`; `staging/csg-book04-true-family/csg-adam-and-eve-were-to-become-true-parents.md`	`staging/csg-book04-true-family/`	Same True-Parents-as-providential-pivot logic. Book04 angle is origin; Book07 angle is participation.
`csg-true-parents-picture-protects-the-home.md`	`[[csg-spirit-world-blessing-of-ancestors]]` (related-ancestor logic)	`/reference/`	Adjacent ancestor-mediated household-protection claim.
`csg-witnessing-creates-ones-second-self.md`	`[[smm-1980s-teaching-street-witnessing-doesnt-grow-church]]`	`/reference/`	Tension: Book07 demands witnessing as primary spirit-world asset; 1980s SMM teaching qualifies that street witnessing alone doesn’t grow the church. Worth a comparative thread eventually.
`csg-blessed-families-establish-god-centered-rules.md`; `csg-family-life-replaces-vague-living-with-purpose.md`; `csg-tradition-is-passed-on-by-parents.md`; `csg-parents-must-first-practice-what-they-teach.md`	`staging/csg-book04-true-family/csg-adams-family-should-have-set-the-original-tradition.md`	`staging/csg-book04-true-family/`	Cluster overlap on family-as-restoration-unit + tradition-by-example; Book07 differentiates with explicit codification rules.
`csg-leaders-raise-members-through-devoted-investment.md`; `csg-church-leader-must-practice-a-public-life.md`; `csg-sex-and-public-money-disqualify-leaders.md`	`[[populist-church]]`; `[[meltdown-worship]]`; `[[worship-leader]]` glossaries	`/glossary/`	Adjacent worship-leader / populist-church concepts already glossed. Book07 atomics give the disciplinary-code side. Cross-link only.
`csg-sermons-must-be-given-with-life-intensity.md`; `csg-true-fathers-sermons-come-from-life-not-books.md`	None obvious in current corpus	—	Sermon-discipline cluster appears Book07-original; no clear cross-batch duplicate.
`csg-completed-testament-age-is-salvation-through-attendance.md`; `csg-attendance-age-demands-the-highest-codified-law.md`	`staging/csg-book10-completed-testament-age/*.md` (general overlap)	`staging/csg-book10-.../`	Whole Book10 batch is the canonical Completed-Testament-Age cluster. Book07 atomics here are the etiquette-grammar slice. Cluster review at finalize.

Tag-registry requests

Proposed tag	Justification	Trigger atomic
`sacrifice`	Used by `csg-church-leader-must-practice-a-public-life` and `csg-service-and-sacrifice-are-the-path-of-true-love` — the path-of-true-love/leader-self-sacrifice cluster reads naturally with `sacrifice` as a distinct tag rather than `indemnity` (more specific) or `love` (too broad). Two atomics in this batch already use it. Recommendation: approve + add to `_meta/tags.md` `Theology — themes` section in the finalize commit, OR replace with `indemnity` / `love` in both atomics.	`csg-church-leader-must-practice-a-public-life`, `csg-service-and-sacrifice-are-the-path-of-true-love`

Linking applied (Phase C)

related: additions: 214 within-batch cross-refs across all 51 atomics (~4.2 avg per atomic). Cluster topology: attendance/CT-Age cluster, tribal-messiah/blessed-families cluster, Cain-Abel cluster, sermon/worship cluster, prayer cluster, indemnity-fund/fast cluster, tithing/frugality/thrift cluster, parents/tradition/education cluster, siblings/spouses/members cluster, living-for-others/service cluster, leadership cluster, ecclesiology cluster.
Inline glossary wikilinks added (Phase C wraps; in addition to wikilinks already present from Phase B): [[spirit-world]] ×2, [[fall|Fall]] ×1, [[indemnity]] ×2, [[restoration]] ×3, [[completed-testament-age|...]] ×3, [[true-parents|True Parents]] ×4, [[cain-abel-pattern|Cain-Abel]] ×1, [[blessing|Blessed]] ×1, [[tribal-messiah]] already wrapped — total ~17 new inline wraps across 14 atomics.
Inline person wikilinks added (Phase C): [[jesus|Jesus]] ×2, [[adam|Adam]] ×3, [[eve|Eve]] ×2, [[abel|Abel]] ×2, [[cain|Cain]] ×2 — total ~11 new inline person wraps.
Suspected duplicates flagged: 21 rows (see table above).
New glossary stubs proposed: 7 (see Glossary section above — attendance, seunghwa, holy-salt, pledge-service, shimjung-candle cluster, indemnity-fund, tribal-messiahship cross-batch).

Validation failures (Phase B)

Atomic	Validation rule failed	Notes
(none observed during atomize)	(none)	All atomics within CSG 500-word cap; resource wikilinks verbatim per ADR-0024; no `status:` field. Phase C pre-flight (read-only) surfaces one tag-registry failure: `sacrifice` tag not in `_meta/tags.md` (used in 2 atomics) — see “Tag-registry requests” above. Resolve by approving the tag or rewriting the two atomics to use registered tags before finalize.

Parked items (Phase D)

Appended to _meta/parking/*.md on finalize.

Threads (4 entries — see _meta/parking/threads.md)
- Whether SMM’s reframing of tithing as “restoration arithmetic” (number nine = fallen world, ten = heavenly) survives critical numerology scrutiny — or whether it’s pastoral metaphor presented as doctrine. Anchor: csg-tithing-is-a-heavenly-duty.
- Whether the Cain-Abel-among-members logic (csg-cain-abel-order-among-members, csg-abel-is-defined-by-public-mindedness) functions as constructive social discipline or as a coercive frame that disables criticism of leadership. Tension worth steel-manning a counter for.
- Whether csg-attendance-age-demands-the-highest-codified-law produces practical conflict with Protestant freedom-from-law / sola-gratia objections (which the CSG text never engages directly).
- Whether csg-witnessing-creates-ones-second-self vs. [[smm-1980s-teaching-street-witnessing-doesnt-grow-church]] represents doctrinal evolution or a context-distinction (institutional vs. individual witnessing).
Questions (6 entries — see _meta/parking/questions.md)
- Should attendance be promoted to glossary or tag (or both)?
- Should sacrifice be admitted to the tag registry, or should the two affected atomics re-tag?
- Should the seunghwa / holy-salt / shimjung-candle etiquette vocabulary be stubbed as glossary terms in a separate batch, or absorbed into the existing hoondokhae glossary entry?
- Is the indemnity-fund (numerical 3-12,000-won schema) doctrinally load-bearing or a 1960s-Korea-specific operational detail? Should indemnity-fund be a sub-entry under indemnity glossary or its own term?
- How does CSG tradition-by-parents-not-schools rule interact with the existing home-church glossary entry?
- What is the canonical CSG term for the “second self” multiplied through witnessing — is it glossable, or only a metaphor?
Web-search (0 entries)
- None. Source-grounded foundation pass; no web lookup required for this batch.

How to review

Open staging/csg-book07-etiquette-and-tradition/ in Obsidian or VS Code.
Read the atomics in any order. Edit, reject, or accept in place. Atomics are filename-keyed wikilinks; moving them later is incidental.
Resolve flagged items in the tables above (suspected duplicates, tag requests, new-stub proposals, validation failures).
- Action required before finalize: decide on the sacrifice tag (approve + add to _meta/tags.md, or re-tag the 2 affected atomics).
Decide which parked questions (if any) should be promoted to /questions/ immediately (default is park).
Say “approved” + any edits. I’ll finalize, hook validates.

Pre-flight hook output

Read-only invocation at end of Phase D (atomics remain in staging/csg-book07-etiquette-and-tradition/; nothing staged for commit).

$ python3 scripts/pre-commit-hook.py
✓ pre-commit checks passed (0 markdown file(s))
 
$ python3 scripts/pre-commit-hook.py --all
✓ pre-commit checks passed (2483 markdown file(s))

Default invocation passes trivially (no files staged for commit). The --all sweep validates every tracked .md in the vault — staging atomics are untracked, so they are not exercised by either invocation above.

To exercise the staging atomics directly (read-only simulation against the hook’s check functions, achieved by monkeypatching subprocess.check_output to return the staging file list in place of git diff --cached):

$ python3 -c "...simulate staging file list..."
✗ PRE-COMMIT HOOK FAILED
  - staging/csg-book07-etiquette-and-tradition/csg-church-leader-must-practice-a-public-life.md: tag 'sacrifice' not in _meta/tags.md registry
  - staging/csg-book07-etiquette-and-tradition/csg-service-and-sacrifice-are-the-path-of-true-love.md: tag 'sacrifice' not in _meta/tags.md registry
 
2 error(s). Fix and re-stage.

Resolution required before finalize: the 2 atomics using the sacrifice tag will fail the hook on the finalize commit unless (a) the tag is approved + added to _meta/tags.md in the same commit, or (b) the 2 atomics are re-tagged to use already-registered alternatives (indemnity and/or love). Recommendation in the “Tag-registry requests” table above is to approve.

All other hook rules — word cap (CSG ≤500), citation grammar (ADR-0024 verbatim anchors), status: field absence, resource-wikilink resolution — pass.

Say “approved” to finalize, hook validates.

Zettle

Explorer

csg-book07-etiquette-and-tradition