weave-democracy-political-theology-and-economy-research

Batch Review — weave-democracy-political-theology-and-economy-research

Source: cluster #1 from _meta/cluster-map.md — democracy-political-theology-and-economy Scope: Stage 1 (research batch) per ADR-0022 — citation verification only, no synthesis Date: 2026-05-22 Variant: research

Summary

Stage 1 shakedown cluster. After upgrade pass and grilling-driven ADR-0022 refinement (load-bearing vs supplementary tier), 4 of 5 threads have [verified] load-bearing counter-args and are Stage-2-ready clean. 1 thread (body-of-perfected-person) has a [flagged-paywall] load-bearing and ships in Stage 2 under the CONTEXT.md L82-83 provisional disclaimer + Stage-2 REVIEW backlog entry.

Output: research-notes.md in this staging directory (becomes _meta/research/democracy-political-theology-and-economy.md on finalize).

Quality-gate disposition per thread

#	Thread	Load-bearing counter-arg	Marker	Stage 2 disposition
1	Three-tracks-progress-separately	Cavanaugh MRV Intro definition	[verified]	Ships clean
2	Democracy-as-providential-vehicle	Schmitt Political Theology (1922)	[verified]	Ships clean
3	God-socialism vs Satan-communism	Centesimus Annus §13 + §35	[verified]	Ships clean
4	Two-types-of-democracy (French Cain vs Anglo-American Abel)	Arendt On Revolution Ch 2	[verified] (chapter, page TBD)	Ships clean
5	Body-of-perfected-person template	Cavanaugh Torture and Eucharist	[flagged-paywall]	Ships provisional per Q3-B; backlog entry

Verified sources (Stage-2 load-bearing)

Source	Citation	Verification method
Centesimus Annus §13, §14, §35	John Paul II (1991)	vatican.va official text, paragraph numbers exact
Schmitt Political Theology (1922) Ch 3 opening	Schwab trans., U. Chicago Press 1985/2005	Cross-confirmed across SEP, U. Chicago Press page, multiple PDFs
Cavanaugh Myth of Religious Violence (2009) Intro	Oxford UP	Wording cross-confirmed verbatim across 4+ independent academic reviewers
Arendt On Revolution (1963) Ch 2 “The Social Question”	Penguin 1990 ed.	archive.org djvu full-text, exact wording, chapter-located; page number TBD
Locke Second Treatise §95, §99	constitution.org full text	Verbatim from primary URL (held for future thread; no cluster-1 thread engages it)

Supplementary sources (acceptable as [secondary] per Q4-B)

Source	Thread served	Status
Milbank Theology and Social Theory (1990)	Three-tracks	[secondary] — famous “secular had to be invented” line across reviews
O’Donovan Desire of the Nations (1996)	Democracy-providential	[secondary] — Puritan Board commentary + Gospel Coalition review summaries
Grudem Politics According to the Bible (2010)	God-socialism	[flagged-paywall] — thesis confirmed via secondary, exact quote pending user supply
Israel Radical Enlightenment / Revolutionary Ideas	Two-types-democracy	[flagged-paywall] — not fetched
Aquinas De Regno	Body-of-perfected-person	[flagged-unverifiable] — both candidate URLs returned 404

ADR-0022 refinement (commit 8747588)

This batch surfaced a gap in ADR-0022’s original quality gate. Refinement committed during this batch:

• Each thread has exactly one load-bearing counter-arg requiring [verified].
• Supplementary counter-args may be [secondary].
• A [flagged-paywall] load-bearing ships with the CONTEXT.md L82-83 “source not located — provisional” disclaimer in the ## Counter-argument section + Stage-2 REVIEW backlog entry (avoids Stage-1↔Stage-2 ping-pong).
• The “still wrestling” mark in ## Response is for response uncertainty, not citation uncertainty.

What you’re reviewing

Read research-notes.md. For each thread’s counter-arg block, decide:

1. Accept the 4 verified load-bearing citations for Stage-2 lift.
2. Accept the body-of-perfected-person provisional disposition, OR supply a Cavanaugh T&E primary quote (archive.org borrow at archive.org/details/tortureeucharist0000cava) to upgrade it to clean.
3. Supply Arendt page numbers (Penguin 1990 ed.) if you have the book — current [verified] carries chapter location only.
4. Reject any counter-arg if you judge the verification misrepresents the source.

Hard rule honored

No fabricated page numbers. No invented quotes. Where the AI could not access primary text, the entry is flagged, not fabricated.

What’s NOT in this batch

• No thread drafting (that’s Stage 2)
• No parking-file mutations (Stage 2 finalize)
• No question promotions (Stage 2)
• No [verified] markers in _meta/parking/web-search.md yet (added at this batch’s finalize)

How to review / finalize

1. Read research-notes.md. Optional supply: Cavanaugh T&E primary, Arendt page numbers, Grudem exact quote.
2. Approve verified items as-is.
3. Approve by saying “finalize the research batch” — AI will then:
   • Copy this REVIEW to _meta/batch-reviews/weave-democracy-political-theology-and-economy-research.md
   • Move research-notes.md to _meta/research/democracy-political-theology-and-economy.md (create _meta/research/ if absent)
   • Mark cluster web-search items in _meta/parking/web-search.md as [verified — see _meta/research/democracy-political-theology-and-economy.md]
   • Delete this staging directory
   • Commit
4. Stage 2 (weaving batch) for this cluster begins next.

Open follow-ups (carry forward)

• Working primary URL for Aquinas De Regno (current candidates broke; supplement-only impact)
• Cavanaugh T&E primary page references (blocking-but-not-blocking per Q3-B)
• Arendt OR page numbers (Penguin 1990 ed.) — chapter location currently suffices

Parked items

Nothing new parked.

Tag-registry requests

None.